Perhaps the dads in your world adore sweet vanilla or candy scents—and that's A-OK. But for those who prefer smokier, spicier aromas, the No.3 Teakwood + Leather candle from Basik Candle Co. is the ticket. Warm and cozy with notes of sandalwood, black pepper and pimento berry, the coconut-wax-blend candle (with a wooden lid) is our kind of handsome.

// $35, baskicandle.com