Skip to Navigation Skip to Content

Is Starbelly Different From The Rest?

Though the name of this Castro newcomer, Starbelly, has most people thinking about Dr. Seuss, I'm going to go ahead and date myself as a '90s teenager by announcing that the restaurants name evokes nothing so much as the Bikini Kill song "Star-Bellied Boy." (Not to be confused with the Hole song "Star Belly"). In that riot-girl anthem the girls rock out, screaming "Star-bellied boy different from the rest, you're so different from the rest, prove you're different from the rest."

Why am I bringing this up? Well, because it was those lyrics that were echoing through my head last night as I waited an hour plus for a table at the brand-spanking new restaurant. I am hungry for something new here in San Francisco, eager for someone to take a chance. Prove you're different from the rest! But, alas, Starbelly is not that restaurant. Owned by two of the partners involved in insta-hit Beretta, Starbelly is a good restaurant. In the Castro it might even be considered a great restaurant, since there is, inexplicably, a dirth of great places to eat in that little hamlet. It is not a second Beretta, mind you, not least of all because they don't have cocktails, a fact that they have more than made up for with a great, affordable wine list and lots of fun beer-based and non-alcoholic drinks. But it does share with Beretta a kind of easy-going menu, and really feels like the kind of place you could go for a few snacks, a pizza (yes, of course, there is pizza on the menu) or a full meal. It's easy like Sunday morning in there (and, bonus, they are open on Sunday mornings, and Saturdays, for brunch, and serve lunch Monday through Friday).

I cut a swath through the menu, and an early stand-out is the excellent porcetta, the meat juicy and redolent of fennel, with a crispy, potato-chip like strip of skin and a bright, acidic salsa verde helping to cut the fat. For $29 you can, and should, add a bottle of Lagrein rose to your order. And in a couple weeks, when the back patio is finished and open for business, you can enjoy this lovely late-summer feast in plein air. So, no, they're not proving to be different from the rest, but they are proving that finally, at long last, there is hope of getting a solid, inexpensive meal in the Castro.