Oh, Fentons. The Oakland staple has been serving up decadent homemade ice cream to loyal fans for over 100 years and even won a cameo appearance in Pixar's UP. But in all that time, I bet you never knew you could order these secret off-the-menu items:

Grilled PB&J 

It sounds kinda weird, but you can order your PB&J buttered and grilled just like a grilled cheese. A carb-loaded combo of all our favorite things. 

Olive Salad Sandwich

Only Fentons old-timers remember the days when the Chopped Olive Salad Sandwich ruled the menu. But even today, you can still order this bad boy of chopped olives mixed with mayonnaise. 

Adult-Size Mac-N-Cheese

Fentons doesn't believe in age limits on good food. The creamery will serve up an adult-size portion...if you ask nicely. 


Fentons: 4226 Piedmont Avenue, Oakland